The Curious Incident of the Dog in the Nighttime Review

Curve, Leicester – until 24th October 2026

Reviewed by Amarjeet Singh

3***

Just as Mark Haddon’s bestselling 2003 novel captivated readers, Simon Stephens’ adaptation delivers an equally stunning theatrical production. By placing a neurodivergent teenager at the centre of the narrative, the story unfolds through a unique and insightful lens. While the National Theatre’s original staging was phenomenal, subsequent productions have also found great success. What usually connects these interpretations is the authenticity of the relationships and a commitment to telling the protagonist’s story in a respectful, non-sensational, and unsentimental way.

However, director Ned Bennett’s current production falls short on these counts. Mostly because the relationships feel strained and disingenuous, lacking the warmth and empathy that make the story so affecting. Attempting innovation, the staging feels overly busy. Eleanor Bull’s set design evokes a brightly coloured preschool play area which is filled with skipping ropes, spongy blocks, falling balls, acrobatics and an imposing ensemble, which clutters the stage rather than enhancing the storytelling. A comfortable balance is never struck. The production tends to alternate between over-stimulating sensory elements and text-heavy, slow-moving dialogue.

The choice to recast the original protagonist, Christopher, as a teenage girl named Chris could have been an interesting creative pivot. It offered an opportunity to explore how autism manifests differently in girls compared to boys. Unfortunately, this nuance is difficult to detect in this production.The portrayal is direct and highly physical, leaning heavily into traditionally masculine traits rather than exploring the ways neurodivergence can present in girls.

This disconnect extends to the supporting cast. Joe McFadden gives a confusing performance as Chris’ father, Ed Boone. Though Ed is written as a patient man with a deep connection to Chris, McFadden delivers a largely one-note performance, often played at an unrelentingly heightened intensity. His monologue towards the end of Act one, which should deepen our understanding of the character and foster greater empathy for him, is overshadowed by a simmering frustration that makes it difficult to understand and sympathise with his actions.

Similarly, Charlie Brooks comes across as almost marionette-like as Judy Boone, lacking a convincing maternal bond. Alex Keenan delivers a strong and often mesmerising performance as Chris, but it is sometimes overshadowed by the busy staging and constant activity unfolding around her. Bridgette Amofah’s performance as Siobhan, the teacher who serves as the warm, grounding anchor of the story, lacks that expected sense of calm, instead portraying the character as commanding and authoritative.

Another distracting aspect of this production is the inclusion of poorly timed humour. The ensemble frequently interrupts serious scenes with comedic bits that detract from the play’s emotional weight. For instance, when Chris is on the verge of a meltdown amidst the chaos of the train station, the ensemble personifies the cash machines and ticket barriers. Rather than reflecting her internal stress and confusion, they dilute the impact with unnecessary gags. Chris’s intense sensory overload and emotional dysregulation are overshadowed by a comedic conductor and shouting commuters, turning what should be a powerful moment into farce. Visual gimmicks further disrupt the tension. The dropping of items from the ceiling, a device used effectively earlier with letters from Chris’s mother, is overdone by the second act. When a large cascade of yellow balls rains down, the intended dramatic effect is lost. Instead, the audience is left watching the ensemble take considerable time to gather them all up and place them into bins.

This is accompanied by a string of other unusual choices. There is a breaking of the fourth wall without clear purpose, a bizarre gnome invasion devoid of context, and unnecessary ensemble acrobatics. Most noticeably, a vivid portrayal of someone using a train toilet takes away from the audience’s ability to empathise with Chris’s specific anxiety about using public facilities while desperate for the toilet, shifting the focus entirely to physical comedy.

The original book remains a wonderful piece of storytelling, and Stephens’ adaptation is still a remarkably piece of theatre. Unfortunately, this cluttered and misjudged production loses sight of what has always made The Curious Incident of the Dog in the Nighttime so powerful, its humanity. In prioritising spectacle, sensory overload and broad comedy over character and emotional truth, it ultimately misses the mark.