Sweet Victory Review

Etcetera Theatre, Camden – untill September 28th 2026

Reviewed by Mike Linane

3***

The American Revolutionary War has been waging for several years with no end in sight. After abandoning battle an American and British soldier spend the last days of the war in the forests of New York … tolerating each other. Although they share the same name, John Smith and John Thomas couldn’t be more different, but right now they only have each other.

This sounds an interesting premise for a one act play but it is so much more than that. This is a play about friendship, communication, man’s need for one another and what the point of war is. It is made all the more interesting as the two soldiers who are bitter enemies on opposing sides of the battle but who equally need each other to survive are played by two women. I don’t know whose idea it was to cast Mikkie-dené Le Roux and Emma Wilkinson Wright in the roles of the two Johns but it is a masterstroke as they play their parts so well. In fact I’m not sure the play would work as well if these parts were played by male actors.

Mikkie-dené Le Roux is very engaging as John Thomas, the American soldier who is taken captive in the woods by British officer John Smith. Through guile, humour and clever questioning John Thomas comes to understand what has made his captor do what he has done to reach the point where they meet.

Emma Wilkinson Wright is equally as good as the uptight John Smith determined to still do his duty as he sees it despite having deserted the front line of fighting. Smith is the complete opposite of Thomas in every way and apart from a small section of the play where we are given a history lesson about the seven years war where the drama sags somewhat it is the relationship between these two characters that keeps us gripped throughout. Will John Smith return to his regiment that he has previously deserted and hand over his prisoner John Thomas or can John Thomas persuade Smith to take a different course of action? Can either of them survive for long in the forests of New York with only wild squirrels to eat? What if one of them becomes sick? Can they rely on the other one to help them get better?

As the play progresses Smith and Thomas get a better understanding of each other merely by talking to each other and this underlines the futility of war and the need for better communication to understand different points of view.

This really is a life-affirming play and a pleasure so watch and one I would highly recommend to all theatre goers who want to see some really good acting in a studio space that will have them leaving the theatre with a smile on their face.