Peanut Butter & Blueberries Review

Leeds Playhouse – until November 2026

Reviewed by Sal E Marino

4**** 

There is something wonderfully ordinary about the beginnings of love: an unexpected conversation, a shared joke, the discovery of a surprising common ground. In Peanut Butter & Blueberries, playwright Suhaiymah Manzoor-Khan takes these small moments and transforms them into a tender, funny and deeply affecting story about growing up, finding your place in the world and allowing someone else into it.

Following its sell-out world premiere at London’s Kiln Theatre, this performance piece arrives at Leeds Playhouse with a story that feels both intimate and universal. At its heart are Hafsah (Humera Syed) and Bilal (Kashif Ghole), two university students living away from home, navigating the uncertainties of adulthood and discovering, somewhat unexpectedly, that they might be falling in love.

Hafsah is thoughtful, ambitious and fiercely independent, with her books and writing close to her heart. Bilal is more laid-back, cheeky and seemingly content to muddle through university life. Their differences provide plenty of comic opportunities, but it is the gradual discovery of what lies beneath their contrasting personalities that gives the play its emotional depth. And, of course, there is the wonderfully unconventional sandwich that brings them together. Peanut butter and blueberries might not sound like the most obvious recipe for romance, but here it becomes a delicious reminder that the best connections can arrive when we least expect them.

What makes this production so engaging is its ability to balance lightness with complexity. Manzoor-Khan explores faith, family expectations, personal ambition and the difficult choices that come with growing up, without allowing these weightier themes to overwhelm the joy of the story. The characters are figuring out not only how they feel about each other, but also who they want to become. Love, here, is not a simple escape from life’s complications; it is something that must find its way through them.

Hussain’s direction gives the piece an appealing closeness, allowing the relationship to develop through conversation, glances, awkward pauses and the smallest shifts in body language. The storytelling moves between direct address and scenes between the two characters, inviting us into their private thoughts while letting us witness the sometimes hilarious, sometimes painful reality of their connection.

Syed gives Hafsah a lovely combination of intelligence, vulnerability and quiet determination. She captures the tension between a young woman who knows her own mind and someone still discovering just how much life can surprise her. Ghole brings warmth and comic energy to Bilal, making his easygoing manner both endearing and, at times, revealing. Together, they establish a convincing rapport that makes you want to see their relationship flourish. Their performances find the tenderness beneath the teasing, and the uncertainty beneath the laughter.

At times, however, I felt the audience could have benefited from a little more breathing space. The dialogue is rich with ideas, emotions and observations, and there are moments when a pause would have allowed us to absorb what had just been said before moving on to the next exchange. Giving certain lines and revelations room to settle could have added even greater emotional weight to an already thoughtful piece. Similarly, while the stripped-back staging keeps the focus on the performers, I would have welcomed more music and multimedia to enrich the storytelling. For example, Hafsah’s time in New York is mentioned in dialogue, but we are given little visual or aural sense of the place itself. Carefully chosen images, changes in sound or a subtle musical shift could have transported us there, created a stronger contrast with her university life and helped bring that part of her experience to life. These additions would not need to be elaborate; used sensitively, they could support the narrative without distracting from its intimacy.

What stays with you is the play’s generosity of spirit. It recognises that people can carry complicated feelings, responsibilities and worries while still being funny, hopeful, occasionally ridiculous and wonderfully human. The humour never feels at odds with the more serious moments; instead, it makes the emotional turns all the more affecting. There is real pleasure in watching two people gradually learn to understand one another, even when the path ahead is far from straightforward.

For Leeds audiences, there is an added pleasure in welcoming this work by Leeds-born writer Manzoor-Khan back to the city. Peanut Butter & Blueberries is a refreshing, heartfelt piece of theatre that finds the extraordinary in everyday encounters. Warm, witty and quietly moving, it offers a love story with both its feet on the ground and its heart wide open. Like its unlikely sandwich combination, it proves that the most unexpected ingredients can make something rather special.