Kings Theatre Portsmouth – 21st February 2026
Reviewed by Emma Barnes
5*****
There was a joyful confidence in the way Stage One Youth Theatre approached their latest production at the Kings Theatre, proving that a Golden Age classic like Oklahoma! still has plenty to say when placed in capable hands. Under the direction of Paul Clements, this was a polished and high-energy performance that balanced the show’s iconic charm with a surprising amount of psychological drama.
The production was anchored by a 16-piece live orchestra, providing a rich, well-balanced sound that never overpowered the clear vocals of the cast. Arthur Westmorland (Curly) and Lizzie Codling (Laurey) led the show with professional discipline, their chemistry bringing an authentic and engaging heart to the story. A particular highlight was the dream sequence at the end of Act One; this “fever dream” was effectively staged, successfully shifting the tone to explore Laurey’s internal conflict with impressive depth.
The energy of the territory was captured during the “Kansas City” number. Led by Sam Shirley (Will Parker), the tap dancing was slickly executed and served as a fantastic showcase for the diversity of talent within this youth group. Evie Payne-Simmons was equally wonderful as Ado Annie, navigating the physical comedy and exuberance of the role with natural ease. Joshua Witt navigated the complex role of Jud Fry with skill, successfully flitting between dark menace and a tragic, profound loneliness. We also loved Fraser Ndahiro as the hilarious Ali Hakim serving as a bright contrast to the show’s more serious moments.
A standout creative choice was the casting of Tayla Fallon as Andrea Carnes. By taking this traditionally male role, Fallon created a formidable “second matriarch” character that played brilliantly against Heidi Butcher, who, in her final performance with Stage One, provided a fittingly confident anchor as Aunt Eller.
With a cast of over 50 young performers, the ensemble did a fantastic job of filling the stage with energy and professionalism. We were impressed that the young cast maintained consistent, grounded Midwestern accents that truly brought the characters to life. Great scenery and props combined with the disciplined choreography, the production felt like a vibrant celebration of both the story and the young talent being nurtured behind the scenes, and they looked like they were really enjoying the ride!
Huge congratulations to the entire cast and the support team for a professional, high-quality production that was a genuine joy to watch.