Martin Guerre Review

The Old Vic – until October 31st 2026

Reviewed by Mike Linane

5*****

Composers Alain Boublil and Claude-Michel Schönberg’s Olivier Award-winning musical is reimagined for the London stage with new music, new lyrics (by Annabel Mutale Reed and Paul Hodge), new folk-inflected orchestrations and a thrilling new In The Round staging.

Whilst this is still the same basic story as the previous iterations it is told in a completely new way with some major changes along the way. You think you know Martin Guerre? Think again.

It begins quite simply with young Martin Guerre being forced by his uncle into an arranged marriage with the beautiful young Bertrande de Rois who is the most sort after bride in the village of Artigat. Reluctantly, Martin does what he regards as being his family duty but when it comes to the wedding night Martin is not ready to consummate the marriage and runs away to fight in the war. There he meets and befriends Arnaud du Thil in whom he confides his story and what brought him to fight in the army. From there their story takes a major u-turn that no one would see coming and is the basis for this musical which is partly based on a real-life character and happening.

The music is lush, swerving from emotional ballad to songs of hatred and vengeance in a heartbeat – it is almost symphonic as befits a story of such passion. Only a couple of songs remain from the original version, the others being replaced with equally as good heartrending ballads.

The musical this time is played in the round which I’m not sure entirely works as the performances need a larger stage on which to reach their full potential, but at other times the intimacy of the smaller space works well.

The company is led by Shane O’Riordan as Martin, Liv Andrusier as Bertrande, Colin Ryan as Benoit and Barney Wilkinson as Guillaume (Martin’s rival for the love of Bertrande and who is determined to bring Martin down at any cost). They all are excellent in their roles and are ably supported by the rest of the cast. The vocals are superb throughout with some very strong performances from the entire ensemble.

Directed by Matthew Warchus this show deserves a much longer run in a bigger theatre where the majesty of it all can properly express itself.

This is truly a magnificent show. Musicals of this calibre don’t come along very often so do try to catch it before its run ends if you can – you won’t be disappointed.