Victoria Theatre, Halifax – until 31st October 2026
Reviewed by Lauren Fordham
5*****
Operation Mincemeat: The Musical chronicles the eponymous World War II mission by British Intelligence Officers to divert the Nazi German army’s attention away from the upcoming Allied invasion of Sicily.
This was to be achieved by obtaining a male corpse (christened by the officers as Bill), dressing it as a British soldier who had drowned at sea, planting documents on it ‘revealing’ Allied plans to invade Sardinia instead, and placing it off the coast of neutral Spain, where Nazi spies would discover it and be guided by the misinformation to move their troops away from Sicily, enabling Allied forces to decisively attack it, as it was undefended.
Ben Macintyre’s book brought the story into the public consciousness when it was published in 2010 and it gained further attention in 2021 when it was adapted into a film, directed by John Madden and starring Colin Firth.
Operation Mincemeat: A New Musical was created by comedy troupe SpitLip (consisting of David Cumming, Felix Hagan, Natasha Hodgson and Zoë Roberts) and premiered on 14th May 2019 at the New Diorama Theatre in London.
The cast consists of just 5 actors, playing over 80 historical characters across all genders because of the show’s ensemble cast and the troupe’s intention to avoid cheap, pantomime-dame-style gags and risk distracting the audience from what is at heart a profoundly poignant narrative.
The musical shines a harsh light on the classist, misogynistic and arrogant attitudes of many of the Intelligence officers, insulated as they are by their wealth and lofty positions which prevent them from conscription, with which the ‘common people’ are forced to comply. ‘We were made to give the orders, while lesser men take heed, some were born to follow, but we were born to lead.’
Even within MI5, Ewan Montagu (played by Holly Sumpton) and his Eton pals assert their superiority to and push in front of Charles Cholmondeley (Morgan Phillips) to meet with Johnny Bevan (Jamie-Rose Monk), even though Cholmondeley is the only person with a credible idea.
As other reviewers have also noted, ‘Operation Mincemeat’ has been clearly influenced by the style several other popular musicals, the most obvious being ‘Hamilton’ as many of the songs are delivered as a rap, but to this reviewer the character of Charles Cholmondeley closely parallels Miss Honey in ‘Matilda the Musical’ (and not only because he says I wish I was a maggot.’) Like Miss Honey, who calls herself pathetic for refusing to stand up to Miss Trunchbull, Cholmondeley laments his own lack of self-esteem and initiative, ‘it’s part of my biology to start with an apology, I wish that I could change my life,’ and like Matilda’s magic, his plans quietly come to fruition. Christian Andrews, the imposing but buttoned-up Hester Legatt, would also make an excellent Miss Trunchbull, quiet, but deadly.
Phillips’ physicality and comic timing is impressive especially when he is trying to get Montagu’s briefcase and jumps dramatically every time someone walks through the door. He and every member of the cast is incredibly versatile, seamlessly switching between Received Pronunciation, cockney and Spanish accents as their characters require.
Ben Stones’ set design is just as versatile as the cast is, even though at first it seems deceptively simple; a military office with a strategy chart as a backdrop, a couple of desks and a wheeled staircase. But behind the strategy chart, the wall has hidden doors and entrances which facilitate much of the physical comedy, particularly when Cholmondeley, suspecting Montagu of espionage, is trying to locate his briefcase to see if he has stolen confidential papers to pass to his brother.
But as the show progresses, with a flick of a switch, those benches and desks transform into a pub, a nightclub (aided by Mark Henderson’s disco lighting) a harbour and a submarine (thanks to Mike Walker’s sound design including seagulls and waves, which was so successful I could almost smell the salty breeze.
Lighting was also used effectively to evoke nationalism, such as the colours of the American flag lighting the stage when a second, real Allied pilot is actually forced to land in the ocean near Spain, and impressively, Stones produced an actual plane housing that the pilot (Christian Andrews) sits in, perhaps influenced by Miss Saigon.
Stones also designed Operation Mincemeat’s costumes, which once again appear simple as they are often just caps or headbands to denote different characters, with the glaring exception of pathologist Bernard Spilsbury (Jamie-Rose Monk) whose suit and gloves drip with glittery blood. Rose-Monk also demonstrates great versatility as the uptight authoritarian head of MI5 Johnny Bevan, as well as the flamboyant fraud, Spilsbury.
As well as inducing laughter as the American pilot, Christian Andrews also took the audience’s collective breath away as Hester Leggat, dictating the imaginary letter from their corpse, Bill, to his girlfriend, from which which Leggat segues into talking to her husband, Tom, who died in WWI. The pressure to pretend to others that everything was ok was palpable, as was Legatt’s frustration at their separation, and the simplistic imagery of the neglected roses was as powerful and tear-jerking as any poem by Owen or Sassoon.
Similarly, Sail on Boys, sung when the MI5 turned navy lads set out for Sicily, vowing to live or die together, whether they die or survive, ‘If it’s down, it’s down together, if it’s up, it’s up as one’ is hugely poignant, and evokes ‘Billy Elliot The Musical’s ‘Once We Were Kings, when the pitmen descend into the mine for the last time: ‘All together we will go as one, the ground is empty and cold as hell, but we’ll all go together when we go.’
In his role as administrative assistant Legatt, Andrews also had great chemistry with Jean Leslie (Charlotte Hanna-Williams) who longs to make her mark on the world and not be seen as ‘the woman who makes the tea’, a mantle she eagerly throws off in the Six-esque anthem ‘All the Ladies’, where they fantasise about going into the exciting jobs that the conscripted British men have vacated.
I hesitate to call it a criticism, but the only warning I have to anyone new to the show, is that like Hamilton, if you go in unprepared some of the songs, such as Das Übermensch, are quite difficult to discern the lyrics of, and I enjoyed the show more after my second viewing, when I had learnt them.
As a uniquely challenging ensemble production Operation Mincemeat doesn’t just have one star, it has 5 (and a whole lot of geniuses backstage too), but Holly Sumpton dazzles, her smug, self-centred Montagu is magnetic and I predict her career will soar (with or without a wire.)
But one of the most poignant parts of the show doesn’t involve wires, or glaring lights, or elaborate set pieces at all. When the officers gather to lay a marker for and pay tribute to Glyndwr Michael, the drifter who became ‘Bill’ Martin. It showed that everyone has a purpose and makes an imprint on the world, and no one should ever forget that or feel anyone is beneath them, least of all those in lofty positions of power.
Operation Mincemeat is a show that has something for everyone, to learn, to feel, to laugh, and to reflect on, and its themes of courage, of cooperation and community, and the fact that everyone makes an imprint on the world, whether it’s celebrated or not, resonate even today. Catch it before it sails on by on Saturday, or you’ll miss more than a new breed of trout!

