Yvonne Arnaud Theatre – until 9th February 2019
Reviewed by Heather Chalkley
4****
A smoothly presented production with Doyle’s usual intricacies that only Sherlock Holmes unique talent can figure out. Set in India and London, the creative team have to be commended on an unusual set that gives the atmosphere of both places, strongly supported by a skilled musical score. The interchange of actor musicians flows beautifully. Composer Tristan Parkes and Director Nick Lane have a synergy that creates a well accomplished piece.
Luke Barton (Sherlock Holmes) captures the quirky, dynamic energy of Holmes, keeping the audience engaged throughout. Joseph Derrington (Dr John Watson) is a believable, likable character, reflecting the exasperation of their relationship. Stephanie Rutherford manages to play three very different roles (Mary Morstan, Mrs Hudson, Mrs Smith) with three accents and is part of the musical ensemble as well, all with energy and enthusiasm, bringing some humour to the piece. Also brought in by Christopher Glover as Detective Athelney-Jones, portrayed as Sherlock Holmes perceives him; a policeman plod. This is in direct contrast to Glover’s Dost Akbar, who gives a warmth and an air of calm confidence. Ru Hamilton is clearly an accomplished musician, playing several instruments and several parts (Thaddeus Sholto, Major Sholto, Sherman) seemingly without breaking a sweat. My favourite performance of the night comes from Zach Lee (Jonathan Small, Captain Morstan, McMurdo), offering emotional intelligence that is perceptible to the audience.
Nick Lane has adapted The Sign of Four well to the stage, managing to cover all the intricacies of the characters and plot by including an element of narration in some of the characters. I think Sir Arthur would have enjoyed seeing his work come to life.