Theatre@41, York – until Saturday 4th April 2026
Reviewed by Michelle Richardson
5*****
Pick Me Up is an independent, well regarded York theatre company. Their current production of Next To Normal is currently playing at the cosy Theatre@41 in York. Under the direction of Andrew Isherwod, Next To Normal is an American rock musical, with book and lyrics by Brian Yorkey and music by Tom Kitt.
Though Next To Normal is a musical, this production stands apart from standard American rock musicals, it comes with extra trigger warnings. It addresses topics such as adult themes, mental health issues and disorders, bereavement, and the effects these experiences have on family life.
Initially, the family appears to be a typical, well-functioning unit, with the added dynamics of raising teenagers. The day begins with Diana (Monica Frost) preparing sandwiches for her family to take to school and work. However, the morning quickly becomes chaotic when the bread falls onto the floor, and Diana is seen manically buttering each slice while on her hands and knees. It soon becomes evident that she is experiencing challenges related to bipolar disorder, and her condition is deteriorating. Her husband Dan (Dale Vaughan), feels helpless and doesn’t quite understand his wife’s turmoil, but he is unwavering in his support. Natalie (Niamh Rose), their daughter, experiences feelings of neglect and misunderstanding. Despite being a grade A student with a strong interest in music and a new boyfriend, Henry (Fergus Green), who provides moments of respite amongst the turmoil. She becomes increasingly frustrated, especially after a no show by both parents to her recital. Natalie begins to exhibit rebellious behaviour as her mother’s condition deteriorates. There is a son (Matthew Warry), who has a close connection with his mum and only really interacts with her. It is not until much later in the play that you learn his name is Gabe.
The cast is outstanding. Every actor gives a performance that adds real depth and emotion to each character they play. Frost’s portrayal of Diana is particularly gripping, realistically portraying her bipolar journey. Vaughan is full of energy, full of hope, then desperation and hopelessness. You can’t help but feel his pain. Rose is fabulous as Natalie, full of depth and her vocals are rich, raw and heavy with emotion. Warry gives an outstanding performance as Gabe, he is a raw talent. His interactions with his mother Diana are authentic and his presence on the stage is compelling to watch. Ryan Richardson plays both psychiatrists, embracing his inner Rock God for Dr Fine.
The multi-level set presents a straightforward, moody atmosphere, representing the family home. Throughout the performance, the live band, under the direction of James Robert Ball, remains visible at the rear of the stage, seamlessly incorporated into the production. Their interpretation of the rock-influenced score significantly adds depth to the story telling. Experiencing live music in the theatre always enhances the overall performance.
This show is not afraid to explore the complexities of mental health disorders, and it doesn’t soften the reality of Diana’s experience and the impact on all around her.. The constant adjustments of medication, the feeling of forever popping of pills, just to stay stable, then the portrayal of controversial electroconvulsive therapy, which is unsettling to watch. It is brutal to witness a person losing essence of themselves, where everything feels invasive and desperate, making these moments intensely powerful.
I must confess that I had not previously heard of this show and all I read about it before I attended was the trigger warnings. When I do go to see a new show I like to go in blind, so as not to be unduly influenced. I anticipated the content mentioned in the warnings, but I didn’t expect how personally affected I would feel. The show touched on an experience that my close family has gone through, and I don’t want to reveal too much of the shows storyline. He had the same thing, the same outcome, was the same age then and now. As the similarities became clear, I felt my stomach drop, that was heart wrenching.
This production of Next To Normal delivers raw, emotional, and powerful performances that draw out strong emotions, and at times is an uneasy watch. Nevertheless, it is compelling to watch, I was mesmerised from start to finish. It is a must-see for anyone who appreciates powerful storytelling and outstanding theatre.