Apollo Theatre – until 26 January 2026, then touring UK until March
Reviewed by Claire Roderick
5*****
Cornley Drama Society delivers consummate Christmas chaos as Mischief tackle Dickens.
Writers Henry Lewis, Jonathan Sayer and Henry Shields have all the familiar characters return, with their foibles ramped up to eleven. Beginning with the audition process, with eternal optimist Annie (Nancy Zamit) appreciating every candidate while Chris (Daniel Fraser) despairs and decides that nobody can match his acting skills and casts himself as Scrooge, the big gags in the second act are set up early. Interminable production team meetings are held, the eternally enthusiastic but untalented Max (Matt Cavendish) rehearses, and hapless Dennis’s (Jonathan Sayer) inability to learn any lines leads to his script being printed on multiple props. Meanwhile poor Jonathan (Greg Tannahill) is still suffering from the trauma of playing Peter Pan and cannot face heights – or even singing high notes. Deluded thespian Robert (Henry Lewis) thinks he is perfect for the part of Scrooge, even though he hasn’t read the script, and Sandra (Sasha Frost) still dreams of playing Russell Crowe’s dead wife in a movie one day – she can now play all 3 – yes 3 – emotions!
A mishap with Chris’s model box means that the set builder has a very different design to Chris’s original, resulting in a confectionary catastrophe and a truly terrifying Tiny Tim. Throw in some sabotage from Robert as he continually tries to incapacitate Chris and take over the role of Scrooge mid-performance, and stage manager Trevor’s (Chris Leask) relaxed attitude to health and safety, and Chris Beans’ Dickensian vision is doomed. The characters foibles are well known to Mischief fans, and writers Henry Lewis, Jonathan Sayer and Henry Shields dig deeper into their relationships in this production, developing a backstage parallel to Scrooge’s transformation as tyrannical micromanaging director Chris has his own epiphany after the disastrous first performance where he rewrites Dickens’ onstage.
Director Matt DiCarlo directs skilfully and Libby Todd’s fantastic set, lit by David Howe, is a masterpiece. Roberto Surace’s costumes are a triumph, especially the three ghosts of Christmas: Nancy Zamit has a hoot as the weirdly leggy Christmas past, while poor Henry Lewis is a very literal take on Christmas present. Chris Leask’s physical comedy in the towering Christmas yet to come costume is absolutely brilliant, dispelling any fear of younger audience members.
The physical, sight and verbal gags come at pace, and most hit the spot brilliantly. Bellringers, execrable choreography, insane multi-role playing, Chris and Robert’s onstage war – and Tiny Tim’s long-awaited entrance all have the audience in stitches. And, as any Mischief fan knows, Chris eventually loses it with the audience for laughing at his show – Daniel Fraser does apoplexy very well, and the Christmas audiences are really up for goading Chris Bean in true panto style.
Packed with warm-hearted silliness and genuine belly laughs, Mischief’s Christmas Carol Goes Wrong is the Christmas gift that keeps on giving.
UK Tour Dates
Nottingham Theatre Royal 27 – 31 January 2026
Aylesbury Waterside Theatre 3 – 7 February
Edinburgh Festival Theatre 10 – 15 February
Glasgow King’s Theatre 17 – 22 February
Canterbury Marlowe Theatre 24 February – 1 March












